My scoring scale runs from 0 to 100–at least in theory. In practice, I have (so far) never given a score above 97, and the low end of the scale is even lonelier. Here is a rough guide to what my scores mean:

95-100 Anything in this range is true nectar of the gods stuff. This is rarefied air–incredible and truly memorable whiskies that are among the best I’ve ever tasted. If you like whisky, you should run, not walk, to try some.

90-94 Superior whisky that is either great on its own merits, or such an exemplar or its style that it deserves attention. You definitely want to try it, and it’s a must-have for any whisky collector who can afford it.

80-89 Excellent whisky. I’d strongly recommend that you try it, and it’s probably something you’ll want to have around if you’re a serious collector.

70-79 Good to very good whisky. It may not be extraordinary, but you’ll probably enjoy it. I’d recommend that you try it, especially if you’re a serious whisky enthusiast looking to taste as widely as possible. It’s worth buying a bottle if the price is right.

60-69 Decent whisky. It may be a little uninspired, or have some noticeable flaws, but the overall experience will probably be pleasant, if not memorable. I’d recommend trying it if you’re an enthusiast who wants to try everything. I wouldn’t recommend buying a bottle unless you’re a serious whisky collector who wants a little of everything, or unless budget is a significant factor and it’s cheap.

50-59 Flawed whisky. Whisky scoring in this range either has flaws that are impossible to ignore, or is severely lacking in personality and character. The experience will be, at best, pleasant. I can’t, in good conscience, recommend whiskies scored in this range, although the serious enthusiast may find moments of enjoyment or interest.

40-49 Mediocre whisky. Whisky scoring in this range is either so bland and anodyne that it might as well be vodka, or the flaws are becoming so severe that the experience is no longer especially pleasant. Drinkable, but just barely. I do not recommend anything in this range, even to completionists: if you want to ignore my rating, do so at your own risk.

30-39 Bad whisky. Possibly acceptable if mixed, but definitely not for drinking straight. Avoid outside (possibly) cocktails.

0-29 Where angels fear to tread. This is whisky bad enough to detract from a cocktail, and you definitely don’t want to drink it straight.

If you’d like to learn more about my tasting methodology, check out this post.

If you want to learn more about my overall tasting philosophy, check out this post.